Human Experience Designer
Affective Interaction Explorer
Speculative Art Attempter
Social Robotics Practitioner
Projects
About
What People Say
A detailed review of the MUJI CD player, examining its unique wall-mounted design, intuitive user interface, and reflection of Japanese minimalist principles.
# Minimalist Design Principles
# Intuitive Interaction
# Spatial Integration
Critical Design Review · Professional Writing · Cultural Context Analysis
Whenever you walk into a MUJI store, your attention will likely be drawn to the unique, delicate CD player hanging on the wall. You may not be a music enthusiast, nor do you have the strong inclination for decorating your life with distinctive design pieces, but you feel the immediate allure the moment you are confronted with this exquisite little thing — you cannot resist pulling the cord, and then enjoy the soothing melodies that emerge from the box. It is so mundane yet intriguing, like a spiritual pillar that calms the restless soul, evoking your pursuit of ultimate simplicity and authenticity in this overwhelming city life. As one of the most recognized products of the Japanese retail company MUJI, this CD player comes from the late 1990s, when industrial design works were simplistically designed and homogenized, but has continued on the market even until today’s digital era. Despite that it has barely changed in form and function over the past two decades, developments in the economy, culture and the public’s cognitive values have continuously prompted the industry to ponder and critically evaluate its contemporary significance, impact, and the “Without Thought” design philosophy behind it. Reflections on this product evolve over time and are worth revisiting in this day and age.
Wall-mounted CD players displayed in New York City MUJI store
The CD player is based on the mechanics of traditional disc readers but applies a fresh interpretation and highly intuitive aesthetics. Taking it out of the package, you are greeted with a clean, neat square box on which a slightly recessed round container is integrated with the sleekly streamlined optical disc drive. The black module, embedded with small, delicate mechanical components, contrasts with the pristine, cream-colored panel, just like the subtle conflict between radical industrialization and simple living. Today, however, this visually harmonious optical drive also brings a nostalgic feeling aroused by the evolution of technology, taking people back to the time when multimedia was not so readily available and a simple CD could stimulate heartfelt happiness. The exterior of the panel is decorated with delicately carved holes that radiate outward around the central disc, ultimately reaching the rounded rectangular profile. When hung on the wall, the wire at the bottom droops freely, constituting the most characteristic and creative part of this product. It functions not only as a power cord but also as a switch itself that can activate the player with a simple pull. Alternatively, several physical buttons can also be found on the top of the device but are not expected to be the main methods of control. The highly straightforward, refined and aesthetically pleasing design of this product stands out as a beacon of simplicity amidst the complexity of industrial design, awakening a reflection on the blind pursuit and necessity of “sophistication” and “functionality” by challenging the general perception of CD player’s traditional forms — no need to hide the beautiful disc in a dark container; adding an inordinate number of buttons is reckless; even the optical drive’s covering can be eliminated. Moreover, its distinctive interaction is also boldly unconventional, refining the CD player to be further intuitive. Since the gesture is so effortless that it can be thoroughly integrated into daily behaviors, chances are you almost forget the presence of this player as an electronic device.
The MUJI CD player without disc installed
This highly intuitive interaction and form are driven by the “Without Thought” design philosophy advocated by the designer of this product, Naoto Fukasawa. The discussion of unconscious design has been around since the time of Plato and Aristotle, but was first introduced to the design sector by this renowned Japanese designer, and the first successful application is commonly considered this CD player. Fukasawa claims that good designs should be combined with “without thought” scenarios in users’ lives, allowing the design to dissolve into behaviors, ultimately achieving a harmonious relationship between humans and objects and naturally evoking a beautiful flow of emotions. As a quintessential case, this CD player comprehensively embodies the charm of this theory from two aspects. First, the player’s cord switch intuitively triggers the user’s desire to pull it, which corresponds to the “action stimulation” proposition of this philosophy. A successful “Without Thought” piece requires careful consideration of people’s implicit memories constructed by life experiences and leveraging these memories to stimulate unconscious behaviors towards the design work. Simply put, familiar operations should be applied to allow users naturally use the product without learning. In the creation of this CD player, Fukasawa cleverly appropriated people’s memory of a kitchen ventilation fan: pull it once and the blades start turning, then pull it again to stop it. When meeting the CD player for the first time, users may have no idea how to use it, but the impression of the ventilation fan will prompt them to pull the cord instinctively, then everything is clear.
In addition, the user experience of this CD player also creates an empathic space that promotes people to feel, recall and associate, echoing the emphasis on natural enjoyment and emotional resonance in the “Without Thought” philosophy. Fukasawa sums it up simply as “making people happy.” Think back to a time when you used an appliance with a pull cord switch: it might be a lamp in your childhood that gently spilled light onto your desk after being turned on, or it might be an old fan that smoothly spilled cool breeze onto your body on a hot summer day. These emotional feelings are too abstract to be recorded and stated, but are successfully reproduced on a CD player with the help of the same user experience. When you pull the cord on it, you will see the disc slowly start to rotate under the drive of the mechanical module, followed by the beautiful music spilling in your ears and floating in your room, giving you a long-lost sensual immersion. Everything is happening so naturally, including your unconscious enjoyment and those lovely memories. That is the power of “Without Thought” design.
Nevertheless, the significance of this CD player and its “Without Thought” design philosophy is more than the presentation of a novel creation but the manifestations of the brilliant Japanese culture and its widespread social impacts. A phenomenal influence is the Japanese Zen philosophy. Zen Buddhism was first introduced to Japan from China in the 12th century and gradually developed into the Japanese Zen system, which advocates a spiritual world of meditation, emptiness, peace and true nature. In the centuries that followed, Zen philosophy profoundly influenced the Japanese people’s rigorous perception and application of aesthetics. Representative examples include traditional Japanese flower arrangement (ikebana), landscape design, and the art of dry gardens (karesansui). However, in the rush to recover economically post-WWII, Japanese manufacturers started to pursue complex functionality and mass production while neglecting the emotional appeal of the user as a human being, producing homogenized products. It was not until the 1990s that Naoto Fukasawa, who had returned from overseas, brought his thoughtful understanding of the harmonious balance between people and the environment back to his home country and designed this CD player as the first practical interpretation of his reflections. The “emptiness” of unnoticeable buttons, the ease of communication with users, and the peaceful atmosphere it creates make this CD player a signal that Japanese Zen has returned and started melting into industrial designs. Besides, its intuitive use, requiring no instructions, also mirrors the “Furyumonji” (do not rely on the text) theory of Japanese Zen. As time goes by, this CD player, along with other design practices that embrace Zen philosophy, has further influenced the pursuit of “minimalist aesthetics” in contemporary Japanese art, contributing to the widely acknowledged simple and neat style of Japanese design in today’s modern society.
Another subtler social impact is people’s increasing appreciation of authentic lifestyles and sustainable values. To be precise, this impact is a joint effort between the CD player and its company, MUJI. Since its inception, MUJI has been dedicated to creating a simple, stress-free yet quality lifestyle with affordable and durable products, just like the meaning of its name in Japanese — “no-brand, quality goods”. As an iconic work during MUJI’s rapid commercial growth, the CD player also inherits this concept and guides a path to pleasant lifestyles. In a 2018 interview, Naoto Fukasawa mentioned that even in today’s world where online streaming multimedia is prevalent, this CD player is still appreciated by people simply because “their lifestyle needs it”. In addition, MUJI firmly rejects luxury packaging and the waste of resources, aspiring to produce sustainable merchandises that are not constrained by the times and trends. They select unfinished or natural materials for production, highlighting the essential functions of the product while resisting industrial interventions such as painting and dyeing. These pursuits are also implemented in this CD player’s manufacturing, which Naoto Fukasawa interprets as a just “enough” strategy. Thus, it is observed that although MUJI does not deliberately emphasize itself to be sustainable, its business practices have subliminally influenced the general public, especially the younger generation, to embrace an authentic and sustainable lifestyle.
However, time also polishes off the cheerful appearance of things and reveals their weaknesses, just like the various drawbacks and negative impacts of this CD player, starting with the mechanical and functionality. Unconventional designs always struggle with stability on account of the challenge against industry standards. The direct exposure of the disc would easily draw dust and grit into the optical drive and damage both the discs and the machine, threatening the unit's durability. Its lackluster sound quality is also a widely criticized flaw. Besides, traditional CD records have long been obsolete as technology evolves. But as a commercial product, this player refuses to address emerging demands such as USB interface, digital audio decoding and wireless connectivity. These increasing limitations have made the CD player more of a decorative object with aesthetic appreciation than a useful product, contrary to the advocacy of reducing fancy decorations and highlighting practical needs promoted by MUJI itself. In addition, with the 20-year journey of this CD player, the issues above have inspired the reflection on the widespread adoption of minimalism and the scrutiny of MUJI’s business practices. People started to see that the aggression of minimalism in contemporary consumer and aesthetic culture had developed it into a kind of elitist show-off, divorced from its pragmatic nature and become a means for capitalists to glorify their business rhetoric and stimulate excessive consumption, implying that owning this CD player is an essential step toward an ideal life. These thoughts also led to the image crisis of MUJI, where people realized that the company was marketing a fantasy, utilizing the noble interpretation of helping you build a quality life to ultimately satisfy their greed for interests. Like this CD player, its price of over 200 Australian dollars has exceeded those of many excellent music players on today’s market. Isn’t the excessive publicity of “no packaging” a packaging itself?
Despite the shortcomings identified from the commercial perspective, it is undeniable that the emergence of this CD player as an artistic creation and the school of “Without Thought” design it initiated remain constructive to the industry’s enlightenment. Today, as a tried and true classic, this CD player has been a collection in the Museum of Modern Art and the Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum in New York City, and the Victoria and Albert Museum in London. Meanwhile, it will continue to reside on the shelves of worldwide MUJI stores, waiting for its timeless glory to be discovered. Even though 20 years have passed since its birth, it is still a beacon of innovation in a homogenized design industry, nurturing the practitioners’ reflections around intuitive aesthetics and anthropocentric harmony, which inhabits along with our spiritual aspiration toward beauty, uniqueness and authenticity, and will never cease.
Budds, D, ‘Naoto Fukasawa on Designing with Objectivity and Interaction in Mind’. in Fast Company, Mansueto Ventures, 2015, <https://www.fastcompany.com/3052429/naoto-fukasawa-on-designing-with-objectivity-and-interaction-in-mind> [accessed 7 July 2022].
Chayka, K, ‘The Oppressive Gospel of “Minimalism”’. in The New York Times, 26 July 2016, <https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/31/magazine/the-oppressive-gospel-of-minimalism.html> [accessed 10 July 2022].
Dumoulin, H, JW Heisig, & PF Knitter, Zen Buddhism, a History: Volume 2, Japan. New York, Macmillan, 1990.
Eisenberg, TR, ‘Muji Wall-Mounted CD Player’. in swissmiss, 2008, <https://www.swiss-miss.com/2008/08/muji-wall-mount.html> [accessed 9 July 2022].
Elizabeth, K, ‘An Approach to Create a Commercially Successful Portable Electronic Audio Device through Design and Marketing’. in Auburn University, 2020, <https://etd.auburn.edu/handle/10415/7173> [accessed 8 July 2022].
Fukasawa, N, Naoto Fukasawa. London; New York, Phaidon Press, 2007.
Goto, T, M Sasaki, & N Fukasawa, The Ecological Approach to Design. Tokyo, Tokyo Shoseki, 2004.
Hirano, T, ‘The Development of Modern Japanese Design: A Personal Account’. in Design Issues, 7, 1991, 54.
IE School of Architecture & Design, ‘Naoto Fukasawa: the Iconic MUJI CD Player’. in YouTube, 2018, <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8cwQ-25mK1U> [accessed 14 October 2020].
Kahn, CH, ‘Sensation and Consciousness in Aristotle’s Psychology’. in Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie, 48, 1966.
Lee, R, The Influence of Zen on Contemporary Aesthetics in Decorative Arts and Interior Design. , 24 February 2022, <https://digitalcommons.sia.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1107&context=stu_theses> [accessed 9 May 2022].
Leelapanyalert, K, J Makaramani, & S Rujichaiyawat, ‘MUJI as a Sustainable brand: Would This Strategy Deter Them to Thrive further?’ in Academy of Asian Business Review, 3, 2017, 75–93.
MUJI, ‘MUJI Presents “MUJI Is Enough” with Naoto Fukasawa’. in MUJI USA, 2015, <https://info.muji.us/2015/10/07/muji-presents-muji-is-enough-with-naoto-fukasawa/> [accessed 8 July 2022].
Muji, Muji. New York Rizzoli, 2010.
‘Muji Wall-mounted CD Player’. in Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum, Smithsonian Institution, <https://collection.cooperhewitt.org/objects/35520927/> [accessed 6 July 2022].
‘Why is MUJI called Zen design?’ in InterAction Green, 2016, <https://www.interactiongreen.com/muji-zen-design/>.
Xu, P, ‘Without Thought’ Philosophy of Design Applied to Product Design. , 22 July 2013, <https://etd.ohiolink.edu/apexprod/rws_etd/send_file/send?accession=ucin1378113030&disposition=inline> [accessed 7 July 2022].
Yang, JY, The Pricing Puzzle: How to Understand and Create Impactful Pricing for Your Products. in The Pricing Puzzle, 1st ed., Cham, Springer International Publishing, 2020, pp. 135–140.
‘Zen-inspired Arts’. in InterAction Green, <https://www.interactiongreen.com/home-2/zero/what-is-zen/zen-art-ultimate-minimalism/>.